ingiliz eleştirmenlerden kompakt hb yorumları ve puanlamalarına göre sıralama | SCW - Seat Club World - Seat, Seat Forum Türkiye
  • Merhaba Ziyaretçi hoşgeldin !
    Forumdan daha fazla yararlanmak için buradan kayıt olunuz
    Hello Welcome to Guest!
    Register here to benefit more from the forum

ingiliz eleştirmenlerden kompakt hb yorumları ve puanlamalarına göre sıralama

mayham85

Kayıtlı Üye
Katılım
26 Ağu 2009
Mesajlar
3,915
Beğeniler
48
Yaş
32
#1
nette dolaşır iken rastladığım bir site ve oradaki yorumlar ile puanlara göre kıyaslamalar ile ilgili ilginç bir konu açmayı düşündüm.

site yorumlarına göre liste:

1. vw golf mk6 (4,5-5)
2. ford focus mk3 (4,5-5)
3. mazda 3 (4,5-5)
4. seat leon (4,4-5)
5. ford focus mk2 (4,4-5)
6. Renault megane 3 hb (4,3-5)
7. Hyundai i30 hatchback (4,3-5)
8. citroen c4 (4,3-5)
9. Honda Civic hb (4,3-5)
10. Peugeot 308 (4,1-5)
11. Opel (vauxhall) astra (4,1-5)
12. alfa romeo guiletta (3,9 -5 )
13. toyota auris (3,9 -5 )


golf mk6

puan: 4.5 /5

http://www.carbuyer.co.uk/reviews/volkswagen/golf/hatchback/review

PROS: (+)
Solid build, strong image
Comfortable, quiet cabin
Decent economy
CONS: (-)
Not as engaging to drive as Ford’s Focus
Optional extras can be expensive
Boot isn’t as big as Honda Civic’s

Seat leon

puan: 4.4 /5

http://www.carbuyer.co.uk/reviews/seat/leon/hatchback/review

PROS: (+)
Sporty feel in the cabin
Massive choice of engines
Spacious inside
CONS: (-)
Isn't as comfortable as many rivals
Boot is too small in this sector
Noisy, especially the diesels

Toyota Auris

puan: 3.9 /5

http://www.carbuyer.co.uk/reviews/toyota/auris/hatchback/review

PROS: (+)
Easy to get comfortable behind the wheel
Lots of cabin storage space
Fuel economy of HSD hybrid
CONS: (-)
Regular petrol and diesel engines lack power
Slightly too much wind, tyre and engine noise
Ride quality isn’t as smooth as it could be

Honda Civic hb


http://www.carbuyer.co.uk/reviews/honda/civic/hatchback/review

puan: 4.3 /5

PROS:
Comfortable driving position
Unique sporty looks
Big boot and versatile storage
CONS:
Uncomfortable over bumps at low speed
Limited rear headroom
Poor visibility out the back

Mazda 3

http://www.carbuyer.co.uk/reviews/mazda/mazda3/hatchback/review

puan: 4.5 /5

PROS:
Stylish exterior
Proven reliability
Great value for money
CONS:
Interior styling a little cluttered
Rear legroom is lacking
Poor economy from the petrol versions

Ford Focus MK2 hb

http://www.carbuyer.co.uk/reviews/ford/focus/hatchback/review

puan : 4.4 /5

PROS:
Great build quality
Excellent to drive
Wide choice of models
CONS:
Steep depreciation
Entry-level cars lack equipment
Smaller engines low on power

Opel (vauxhall) astra

puan : 4.1 /5

PROS:
Quality finish to interior
Cabin comfort
Punchy turbo petrol engines
CONS:
Depreciation
Fussy controls
Questions over reliability

Renault megane 3 hb

http://www.carbuyer.co.uk/reviews/renault/megane/hatchback/review

puan: 4.3 /5

PROS:
Excellent build quality
Most models are comfortable
Good value for money
CONS:
Five-door’s styling is a little bland
Not as practical as some rivals
Confusing array of trim levels

Peugeot 308

http://www.carbuyer.co.uk/reviews/peugeot/308/hatchback/review

puan: 4.1 /5

PROS:
Well built, classy interior
Very safe
Excellent comfort at speed
CONS:
Relatively poor resale values
Reliability is below average
Basic kit on entry-level models

citroen c4

http://www.carbuyer.co.uk/reviews/citroen/c4/coupe/review

puan: 4.3 /5

PROS:
Huge boot
Very comfortable
Generous standard equipment
CONS:
Not exciting to drive
Automatic gearbox is jerky
No engine option under 100g/km of CO2

alfa romeo guiletta

puan : 3.9 /5

PROS:
Interesting looks
Superb MultiAir petrol engines
Stylish cabin layout
CONS:
Uncomfortable driving position
Cramped rear space
List prices are on the high side

Hyundai i30 hatchback

puan: 4,3/5

http://www.carbuyer.co.uk/reviews/hyundai/i30/hatchback/review

PROS:
Low price and brilliant warranty
High levels of standard equipment
Lots of cabin space
CONS:
No version is very quick
Some cabin plastics could be better
Interior design slightly bland
 

picassoner

Kayıtlı Üye
Katılım
9 Kas 2009
Mesajlar
927
Beğeniler
355
Yaş
38
#2
bence tam isabet yorumlar. teşekkürler emre güzel paylaşım olmuş.
 

YCO

Kayıtlı Üye
Katılım
26 Ağu 2009
Mesajlar
22,339
Beğeniler
79
Yaş
30
#4
Trendline beyaz Golf 6.. :eek:key:




puhaha
 

37fbli

Kayıtlı Üye
Katılım
11 Ara 2010
Mesajlar
3,267
Beğeniler
28
Yaş
26
#5
ilk dörde bakarak leon 1. olması lazım :D güzel paylaşım teşekkürler...